If the equal rights of Palestinian Israeli citizens doesn't convince you, then you're welcome to stick with your opinions. Regarding the non-citizens in the West Bank, of course they don't have equal rights. If that's apartheid in your eyes, then every country in the world engages in it. Having said that, by no means am I saying that living as a Palestinian refugee anywhere (including Syria or Lebanon) is a great way to go through life. That's why I'm all for a two state solution that gives them their own homeland where they can govern themselves, hopefully better than what they've done with Hamas or the PA. As long as they let Israel live in peace, Israel will let them live in peace too.